Klage gegen Sozialhilfe-Algorithmus in Frankreich

In France, Millionen Menschen beziehen Sozialhilfe aus der Caisses d’Allocations Families (CAF). The “Familienausgleichskasse” has become a family or residential home. If you notice a problem, you can use a (partly) automatic risk assessment from Empfänger-familien. An algorithm separates a hand from persons concerned with dating regularity, with a vermeintliche risks of an overarching choice.

A coalition from 15 Nichtenregierungsorganisationen has now received a target for the system for. The organization of the French NGO La Quadrature du Net (LQDN) has appealed to the Obersten Verwaltungsgericht in France, the Council of State, for eingereicht. Unter den Unterstützenden is auch Amnesty International France.

Verstoß v Anti-Diskriminierungsgesetz

In the critical criticism of organizations on the organized nutzung of personsbezogen Daten und Recruiter des French Behörde een vertoß gegen das Anti-Diskriminierungsgesetz vor. “This system is directly related to human legal standards and the denial of the right to freedom and non-discrimination of the right to the private sphere,” said Agnès Callamard, General Secretariat of Amnesty International.

2023 has the Quadrature du Net über Informationsfreiheitsanfragen Zugang zu dem Quellcode der Software erhalten. When analyzing the NGO analysis, the factor that is a multiplier is a risk for inequitable business operations and the best way in which groups can be approached.

Double punishment

In fact, the vermeintliche risks become greater, it is a small amount, Arbeitslosigkeit or unstable business relocations. If we live in a “benachteligten” Nachbarschaft or a larger part of the Einkommens for most people, it may be that a higher value is achieved. These factors are checked by the system by all employers: an image of a “Verdächtigkeitswert”. You are higher as a person, having exercised control.

People, who live in poor and poor, can enjoy a vermehrt in view of the control roles. “That is a double punishment,” criticizes Bastien Le Querrec, Legal Editor at La Quadrature du Net. The algorithm is based on a political development of the economy.

Algorithmic disk riminierung used in Europe for Skandale management. In the Netherlands, the so-called ‘Children’s Money Affair’ results in an unjustified refund of Child’s Money. In another fall, an automatic tool has a vermeintlichen deployment in carrying out the social work. In the east of the country, the AMS algorithm is based on a study, it is a matter of years in an elongated jurisdiction.

In August, the EU KI Regulation will automatically become the Einsatz-solcher (teil-) automatic Entscheidungssysteme in soziale Bereich stark regulations a year later. The social scoring system is stubbornly verboten in the EU. But since the Definition Solcher Systeme in der Verordnung is vague in content, the Mitgliedsstaaten Schlupflöcher remain open. In the implementation of the AI ​​Regulation, France, aber auch Deutschland, more blockiert, one of the Regulations of AI Systems is a one-off.